Nichiren criticised the established Buddhist schools of his time because he believed their teachings and their closeness to the authorities left ordinary people without a practice equal to their suffering. He argued his case in public and at personal cost. He did not treat ordinary people as the problem.

The world he was arguing in

Thirteenth-century Japan was a hard place to live. Earthquakes, famine and epidemic had shaken the country. Buddhist institutions were wealthy, connected to the ruling class, and often divided by rivalry.

The short answer to why Nichiren criticised other schools in his time is that he thought the stakes were too high for polite silence. In that setting, a debate about which teaching suited the age was not an academic hobby. People believed the outcome had consequences for the country. Nichiren entered that debate with a specific claim: the Lotus Sutra was the teaching for the time, and reliance on anything else had left people without a workable path.

He set out the argument in On Establishing the Correct Teaching for the Peace of the Land, a dialogue between a visitor and a host about why the land was suffering. The answer he gives is not that individuals are wicked. It is that the whole society had turned towards teachings he considered inadequate.

Criticism of a teaching is not contempt for people

This is the distinction that matters most, and it is easy to lose. Nichiren attacked positions, not the worth of the people who held them. His letters are full of ordinary followers who were confused, frightened or ill, and he does not sneer at them.

He also knew what it cost to speak. He was attacked, exiled and nearly killed. That experience shapes the tone of much of his writing: sharp about the argument, often tender about the person.

If you read the criticisms today, read them as part of a thirteenth-century public debate. They were not written as a licence for anyone to be unkind to a neighbour.

Why the argument was so fierce

Three things raised the temperature. First, the stakes were thought to be cosmic, not merely personal. Second, the institutions he criticised had power, and criticism of them was criticism of the establishment. Third, he was operating in a culture where public debate was a recognised way of settling religious questions.

He also insisted that practice should be available without money, rank or long training. That was a democratising claim in a society where access to the Dharma often depended on patronage.

How to hold this today

You can study his arguments without adopting a fighting posture. Some practitioners read the critiques closely. Others focus on the letters of encouragement and leave the polemics to one side. Communities differ in emphasis, and we take no side in those differences.

What remains useful is the underlying question: what kind of teaching actually helps a person in trouble? That question is worth carrying into your own life.

From Nichiren's writings. On Establishing the Correct Teaching is written as a conversation rather than a sermon. A visitor describes the disasters around him, and the host explains them as the fruit of a society that had turned away from the teaching Nichiren trusted.

Try this today. Read one page of the treatise, then write two lines: what he was arguing about, and who he was arguing with. Keep the two separate.

Next step

Why Nichiren Wrote On Establishing the Correct Teaching gives the historical background without the heat. What Is the Latter Day of the Law? explains the idea of the age that shaped his argument, and Is Nichiren Buddhism Exclusive or Intolerant? takes the harder question directly.

If the history has left you with more questions, the newsletter sends one short note each week.